If you have ever stood in the dental aisle holding a box of floss in one hand and looking at a water flosser on the shelf, you are not alone. “Water flosser vs floss” is one of the questions our hygiene team hears most often, usually from patients who know they should clean between their teeth but find string floss frustrating. The honest answer is that both can work well, and the right choice depends on your mouth, your hands, and what you will actually stick with.
Dr. Tricinella and our team at South Tulsa Dental put this guide together to explain what each tool does, what the research really shows, who tends to do better with one or the other, and how to use either one the right way.
Why Cleaning Between Your Teeth Matters
Your toothbrush does a good job on the front, back, and chewing surfaces of your teeth, but it cannot fully reach the tight spaces in between. According to the American Dental Association’s MouthHealthy guide to flossing, that is why the ADA recommends cleaning between your teeth once a day to remove food and plaque, the sticky film that can lead to cavities and gum disease.
Plaque that stays put can harden into tartar along the gum line. The ADA notes that once tartar forms, only a dental professional can remove it, while daily flossing helps keep plaque from building up in the first place. Our article on how to remove tartar safely explains why scraping at it yourself is a bad idea.
Plenty of people skip this step. Cleveland Clinic’s flossing guide cites an estimate that about 1 in 5 adults never floss.
What Is a Water Flosser?
A water flosser is a small device that aims a pulsing stream of water at your teeth and gums. Mayo Clinic’s answer on dental floss vs. water flossers explains that it is also called an oral irrigator or a dental water jet, and that it can wash food out from between teeth and take plaque off them. Most models have a water tank, a handle with a removable tip, and a few pressure settings.
You will often hear people call any water flosser a “Waterpik.” Waterpik is one brand name, and people use it loosely the same way they say Kleenex for any tissue. Several companies make water flossers, and our team does not recommend one brand over another. What matters more is that the device is easy for you to use and that you use it every day.
What String Floss Does Well
Traditional floss is a thin strand of nylon or Teflon that slides between your teeth. Used correctly, you curve it into a C shape around each tooth and gently rub up and down, including just under the gum line. In a Cleveland Clinic article on water flossers, periodontist Sasha Ross, DMD, points out that string floss can reach all surfaces of a tooth, including between the teeth and below the gum line, where a water stream cannot always get to.
Floss is also inexpensive, takes up no space, needs no electricity, and fits in a pocket or purse. Mayo Clinic adds that floss removes plaque in places a toothbrush cannot reach, and less plaque means less gum bleeding and a lower risk of gum disease.
The catch is technique. Dr. Ross notes that many people have never really been shown how to floss well, so we walk through it further down.
Water Flosser vs Floss: What the Research Says
Researchers have compared these tools for years, and the results are more mixed than product ads suggest. Here is what the best evidence shows.
The Cochrane review
A 2019 Cochrane review of home interdental cleaning devices pulled together 35 randomized trials with 3,929 adults. Cochrane reviews follow strict methods for weighing evidence. The authors found that:
- Flossing in addition to brushing may reduce gingivitis (early gum inflammation) more than brushing alone.
- Adding a water flosser to brushing may reduce gingivitis in the short term, around one month, but there was no evidence of a difference in plaque compared with brushing alone.
- In the small number of trials that compared the two directly, there was some evidence that a water flosser may reduce gingivitis more than floss at one month, but not plaque.
- Small interdental brushes may be better than floss for gingivitis at one and three months.
- No study reported serious side effects from any of these devices.
The review rated the overall evidence as low to very low certainty. Most studies were short, and many participants started with fairly healthy gums, so the differences may not matter much in everyday life.
A newer systematic review on plaque
A systematic review published in 2024 in the Journal of Indian Society of Periodontology looked at seven randomized trials that compared water flossers and dental floss head to head in adults. Most of those trials favored water flossers for removing plaque, especially from hard-to-reach spots between teeth. The authors were also upfront about the limits: the trials were small, ran anywhere from a single cleaning to six weeks, and differed so much that they could not be combined into one overall result. The review also pointed out that water flossers cost more than floss, need storage space, and are harder to use away from home.
The study you may see quoted in ads
One 2013 single-use study of 70 adults in the Journal of Clinical Dentistry found that people who brushed and used a water flosser removed 74.4% of whole-mouth plaque, compared with 57.7% for people who brushed and used string floss. That result gets repeated a lot online. It is worth knowing that the study tested a Waterpik device and that one of its authors worked in clinical affairs for Water Pik, the company that makes it. That does not make it wrong, but it is worth weighing against the independent reviews above.
What it means for you
Put together, the research suggests that both tools help, that neither is a clear winner for everyone, and that a water flosser is a reasonable choice for many people. Mayo Clinic puts it simply: if you already floss and you do not have gum bleeding or other problems, there is no need to change.
Pros and Cons of Each
Water flosser
- Easier for many hands. There is no wrapping or threading, which helps people with arthritis or a weak grip.
- Works around dental work. The ADA notes that it can help people with braces or fixed bridges, where floss is hard to use.
- Gentle on gums. Dr. Ross says the pulsing stream is kind to gums and can help reduce bleeding.
- Costs more. The device costs more than floss, and it needs water, counter space, and for many models an outlet.
- Messier at first. Expect some splashing while you get the hang of it.
- Less portable. It is harder to use at work or while traveling.
String floss
- Cheap and portable. A small container lasts a long time and goes anywhere.
- Scrapes the tooth surface directly. It wipes plaque off the side of each tooth and slips just under the gum line.
- Well studied. The Cochrane review found floss may reduce gingivitis when added to brushing.
- Harder to master. Good technique takes practice, and poor technique can leave plaque behind or nick the gums.
- Tricky around hardware. Braces, bridges, and tight spaces can make floss slow and frustrating.
Who May Do Better With a Water Flosser
Mayo Clinic, the ADA, and the 2024 systematic review all point to the same groups of people who tend to benefit most:
- People with braces. Brackets and wires trap food, and threading floss under each wire takes time. A small 2024 trial in BMC Oral Health, funded by the Saudi Society of Periodontology, followed 30 patients with braces for two weeks. Both the water flosser group and the floss group had less plaque and bleeding, and the water flosser group did slightly better, though the difference was not statistically significant. Our article on white spots on teeth explains why keeping plaque off teeth during braces matters so much.
- People with bridges. The false tooth on a bridge sits just above the gums, and food can collect underneath. Our dental bridge guide covers daily care, and our crowns and bridges page explains the bridges our office provides.
- People with dental implants. Dr. Ross lists implants, bridges, and gaps between teeth as the situations where water flossers help most. If you are considering an implant, our dental implants overview explains how they work in general.
- People who struggle to hold floss. Arthritis and other conditions that make it hard to grip can turn flossing into a chore. Mayo Clinic says a water flosser may be useful for anyone who has trouble flossing by hand.
- People who just will not floss. A tool you actually use beats one that sits in a drawer.
When String Floss May Be the Better Fit
- You already floss and your gums are healthy. Mayo Clinic says there is no need to switch.
- You want something simple and inexpensive. Floss costs little and needs no setup.
- You travel a lot or want to clean your teeth at work. A water flosser is bulky to carry, and floss fits anywhere.
If plain floss shreds or catches, Mayo Clinic suggests trying waxed floss. If holding it is hard, a floss holder helps. Small interdental brushes, picks, and soft sticks are other options, and the Cochrane review found interdental brushes may even outperform floss for gum inflammation.
Should You Use Both?
Experts do not completely agree here. Cleveland Clinic’s Dr. Ross sees a water flosser as an add-on to string floss rather than a replacement, noting that it often rinses out bits of food even after brushing and flossing. The ADA and Mayo Clinic present it as one of several good options, especially for people who find other tools hard to use.
A practical way to think about it: if you have braces, a bridge, an implant, gaps between your teeth, or gums that bleed, adding a water flosser to your routine is worth talking over with us. If your gums are healthy and you floss well, floss alone is fine. And a water flosser you use every day beats floss you use twice a month. As the ADA puts it, the most important thing is making it a daily habit.
How to Floss the Right Way
The ADA recommends these steps for traditional floss:
- Break off about 18 inches of floss. Wind most of it around one middle finger and the rest around the same finger on the other hand.
- Hold the floss tightly between your thumbs and forefingers.
- Guide it between your teeth with a gentle rubbing motion. Never snap it into your gums.
- When the floss reaches the gum line, curve it into a C shape against one tooth and slide it gently into the space between the gum and the tooth.
- Hold the floss against the tooth and rub up and down, following the shape of the tooth. Repeat on every tooth, top and bottom, including the back side of your last molars.
Cleveland Clinic’s oral hygiene guide suggests about 10 up and down strokes on each side, and Dr. Ross recommends moving to a clean section of floss as you go.
How to Use a Water Flosser
A water flosser can feel a little strange and messy the first few times, but it is easy once you get the hang of it. Cleveland Clinic offers these tips:
- Fill and set up. Fill the tank with warm water, pick a comfortable pressure setting, and choose the right tip. Many models include an orthodontic tip for braces.
- Lean over the sink. Put the tip in your mouth, then turn the unit on. Stay over the sink with your mouth open and let the water fall into the sink as you go.
- Trace the gum line. Aim the stream at the gum line and the spaces between your teeth, and make sure it reaches every tooth.
- Follow the instructions. Use the device the way the manufacturer recommends. Cleveland Clinic warns that using it the wrong way can irritate the gums.
A couple of other pointers help too. Mayo Clinic advises against sharing a water flosser with anyone, to lower the risk of spreading bacteria, and the maker’s instructions will tell you how to keep the tank and tips clean. When shopping, look for the ADA Seal of Acceptance. The ADA’s water flosser page explains that models with the Seal have been tested and shown to be safe and effective at removing plaque and helping reduce gingivitis.
What If Your Gums Bleed?
Many people stop flossing because their gums bleed, but bleeding is usually a sign that the gums need more cleaning, not less. Dr. Ross explains that bleeding happens because the gums are inflamed, and that in most cases it stops after a week or so of steady flossing with the right technique. Bleeding gums are often an early sign of gum disease, which can usually be turned around when caught early. Our gum disease guide describes the warning signs.
Bleeding that keeps going after a couple of weeks, gums that look swollen or are pulling back, or a bad taste that will not go away are all reasons to come in. Our articles on receding gums and pregnancy gingivitis cover two common situations. Cleaning between your teeth every day also helps with breath, and our bad breath guide explains why.
Flossing and Kids
The ADA says children should start having their teeth flossed as soon as they have two teeth that touch. Parents handle this at first, and most kids can take over around age 10 or 11, when their hands are ready to manage floss or another cleaning tool. Our pediatric dentist guide covers what to expect at your child’s visits.
How Our Team Can Help You Choose
The easiest way to know which tool suits you is to have someone look at your teeth and gums. At your checkup and cleaning, our team can point out where plaque tends to collect, check your gums for bleeding, and suggest a tool that fits your mouth and your routine. Bring your questions along, and we are happy to talk through technique.
Regular visits also catch what home care misses, including tartar that no floss or water stream can budge. Our articles on what happens during a teeth cleaning, what to expect at a dental checkup, and cavity treatment explain more. Our family dentistry page describes how we care for patients of every age.
Water Flosser vs Floss FAQs
Can a water flosser replace string floss?
For many people, yes. Mayo Clinic and the ADA both list water flossers as a good way to clean between teeth, especially for people with braces, bridges, or trouble using floss. Some periodontists, including one quoted by Cleveland Clinic, prefer that patients use a water flosser in addition to floss rather than instead of it. Ask us what makes sense for your gums.
Is a Waterpik the same thing as a water flosser?
Waterpik is one brand of water flosser, and many people use the name for any water flosser. Several companies make them. Instead of focusing on the brand, look for a model with the ADA Seal of Acceptance that you find comfortable and easy to use.
Should I floss before or after brushing?
The ADA says it does not matter, as long as you clean between your teeth thoroughly once a day. If you are too tired at night, the ADA suggests flossing in the morning or after lunch instead.
Can a water flosser hurt my gums?
Used as directed, a water flosser is gentle. The Cochrane review found no serious side effects and no difference in minor gum irritation between devices. Cleveland Clinic notes that using a water flosser the wrong way can irritate the gums, so follow the instructions and choose a pressure that feels comfortable.
My gums bleed when I floss. Should I stop?
Usually not. Bleeding often means the gums are inflamed, and it typically settles after a week or so of regular, gentle flossing. If it does not, or your gums are swollen or sore, schedule a visit so we can check for gum disease.
Ready for a Cleaner Smile? We Can Help
Water flosser, string floss, or both: the habit matters more than the tool. Dr. Tricinella and our team are glad to help you find a routine that keeps your teeth and gums healthy between visits.
You can find us at our office on East 61st Street, a block west of Sheridan. Browse our full list of dental services, book an appointment online, or fill out our new patient forms ahead of time. If dental visits make you nervous, ask about our sedation options. You can also call us at (918) 628-0834.